For those prone to noticing patterns, there is a predictable sequence of events that unfolds whenever a bishop suppresses the Traditional Latin Mass in his diocese. First, the bishop makes an announcement that the Latin Mass is being suppressed. The statement, both in its content and wording, demonstrates shockingly little pastoral sensitivity to those who will be displaced. The callous disregard for the persons affected prompts an angry backlash; the bishop is subsquently lambasted in the Trad media. Anti-Trads, meanwhile, hold up Trads' predictable ire as justification of the crackdown (this is, of course, gaslighting by inverting causality, akin to beating a dog until it bites you and then arguing that the bite justified the beating). This level of delusion beggars belief. When the Latin Masses of Charlotte were suppressed, there was even someone, a relatively well-known commentator—a real special fellow—who actually argued that Charlotte's traditional Catholics should be thanking Bishop Martin for turning them out of their parishes and shuffling them off to a chapel!
Sunday, October 26, 2025
Thursday, October 16, 2025
Why Filipino Catholicism Looks So Cringey: Spectacle and Substance in the Contemporary Church
We are pleased to present a guest article on Catholicism in the Philippines by a long time friend and supporter of this blog writing under the pseudonym Didacus. This essay was composed in response to the recent cringe-inducing video of Filipino seminarians dancing and singing the official Philippine "theme song" of the Synod on Synodality. In this piece, Didacus attempts to answer the question, "Why is Philippine Catholicism so cringey?" It is a deceptively simple question whose answer takes us on an in depth exploration of Philippine history, identity, and pop culture, with especial emphasis on the Philippine "variety shows," which Didacus argues are a template for understanding Catholicism in the Philippines.
Sunday, October 12, 2025
Book Review: Blosser & Sullivan "Speaking in Tongues" Volume 2
Back in 2023 I reviewed Speaking in Tongues: A Critical Historical Examination by Phil Blosser and Charles Sullivan and published by Pickwick Publications. It was an excellent book and an ecumenical venture of the best kind (Blosser is Catholic and Sullivan a Protestant), tackling the Charismatic subculture within both Protestantism and Catholicism with a detailed study of how the Charismatic conception of tongues developed out of the British Irvingite movement of the 19th century, developing into modern Pentecostalism in the aftermath of the Tongues Missionary Crisis of 1906-1909.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)


